Diamond Calculator
Diamond 3D Book
Educational Programs
Testing Laboratory
Diamond Cut Study
Introduction
Recent achievements
Building of cut grading system
Work with scanned diamond models
Example with tilted table
BLResponses
Analysis of illumination
GIA's illumination model
"Brill" software analyses light response
WLR metric and brilliance
Example with mirrors
An observer model
Understanding of brilliance
Practical value of the cut grading system
Acknowledgment
References
  Building of cut grading system  
 

In the present material, we would like to advance the following assertions:

Assertion 1. Diamond cut grading should be based not on measured geometric parameters (a parametric model of the diamond). Another approach, based on analyzing the complete 3D model of the diamond, is much more effective.

Click for play model
Click to enlarge photo
Image generated by the GemAdviser software on the basis of a 3D model of a real diamond, which was obtained by Garry Holloway with a Sarin machine. The same diamond in the face-up position, as viewed through an IdealScope. Photo by Garry Holloway, www.ideal-scope.com

This analysis can be done by means of computer modeling.

Only symmetric stones can be effectively graded on the basis of the geometric parameters. An attempt to correctly grade an asymmetric stone using this approach would face at least two problems.

Namely:

1.1 Taking into account various deviations of the diamond geometry from the perfectly symmetric leads to the necessity of introducing more and more parameters. To correctly describe all these deviations, a very large number of parameters (such as 100 or 200) may be required. To make the grading procedure correct, the interrelation between all these parameters should be analyzed. Otherwise, some negative consequences may arise. This can be shown using the AGS system as an example.

 
  Work with scanned diamond models  
 

Click on any diamond picture below to download corresponding GemAdviser model. Once model is opened by GemAdviser software we also recommend you to click on green "play" button to see this virtual diamond in motion.

Model AGS2
Model AGS3
Click for play model
Click for play model

Q chart
Sarin Reports
Click to enlarge picture
Click to enlarge picture

This system grades each of the cut parameters independently and cannot grade even such evident correlations as that between the crown angles and the pavilion angles. The analyses of these correlations is very complicated if the number of the parameters is about 10 and almost impossible if this number is about 100.

 
© 2002 Sergey Sivovolenko, Yuri Shelementiev, Vladimir Onischuk, Garry Holloway